Seafood Pot Pie with Puff Pastry

This Seafood Pot Pie is filled with a smoky seafood chowder, and topped with golden, flaky puff pastry.

This recipe is sponsored by Wewalka.

My husband loves pot pies.

Pre-made versions of these flaky, buttery pastry-crowned stews appear mysteriously in my freezer without warning– stocked on a whim by the hungry hubs.

And so, as the winter winds began to whip through the nearby trees, and the sky turned grey (and stayed that way)– it was time to conquer the savory pot pie myself.

And of course, I made a seafood version!

This seafood pot pie is rich and filling.  It’s a comfort food that’s perfect for chilly winter days, huddling inside with a blanket, and hiding from the snow.

Want more SOUP recipes?  Try these: Cauliflower Broccoli Soup, Get Well Soup with Onion and Garlic, Vegetarian French Onion Soup

Seafood Pot Pies: Puff Pastry vs Pie Crust

Most of the pot pies that I’ve eaten over the years have been made with pie crust, not puff pastry, and have both a top and bottom crust.

But I have a fluffier solution for your pot pie needs and wants.  A flakier, more delicate solution.

The answer is puff pastry.

This pot pie is made with a puff pastry lid– and no bottom crust.  (The bottom crust is always soggy anyway, right?)

For this seafood pot pie, I wanted the most golden, the most fluffy puff pastry. 

I’m picky.  And that’s a good thing.

For these seafood pot pies, I used my favorite puff pastry– Wewalka’s European-style FRESH (not frozen) puff pastry.  This decadent pastry dough has 64 buttery, flaky layers, and comes wrapped in an oven-safe parchment paper.

(As of 2022, Welwalka is now “Jus-Rol”.)

We won’t use the parchment paper in the oven for this recipe– but it makes a perfect work surface for laying out and cutting the dough!

How Do I Make a Puff Pastry Pot Pie Lid?

Making a puff pastry lid for your seafood pot pie is EASY.

Simply roll out the pastry dough, and place an oven-safe bowl upside down on the dough.  Next, press the bowl into the dough to make an indentation, and cut then around it.

I usually cut out a large piece of dough around the bowl, and then trim it with a paring knife.

Finally, you’ll scoop the already-cooked seafood pot pie filling into the bowl, push the dough down along the edges of the bowl, and bake until the puff pastry is golden and flaky.

Can I Make One Large Seafood Pot Pie Instead of Small Pies?

Of course you can.

Use a casserole dish or deep-dish pie pan instead of the oven-safe bowls to make one large pie instead of individual servings of pie.  The cook-time should remain the same.

What If I Don’t Have Oven-Safe Bowls?

Check the recipe card for tips on how to cook the pastry without putting the bowls in the oven.

Or, use the technique listed above, and serve one larger pie in a casserole dish or pie pan.

What Kind of Filling Goes in the Seafood Pot Pie?

When I think of pot pies– any kind of pot pies– I always picture a rich, creamy filling.

And when I think of rich and creamy seafood– my mind immediately goes to clam chowder.  Decadent, warming clam chowder.

Except I didn’t want regular clam chowder, I wanted a SMOKY seafood chowder.  The filling for this pie is made with clams and smoked fish.

Where Can I Find Smoked Fish?

Check the canned fish aisle.  I love this chowder with smoked herring (or kipper snacks), but it’s also delicious with smoked oysters and smoked trout.

If you prefer, you can also find smoked trout in the refrigerated seafood section.

If you want to use salmon, you can– but make sure that it’s hot-smoked salmon (it’ll look plump, like a cooked fillet), and not lox.

Not sure what the difference is between hot-smoked salmon and lox?  Read this.

Enjoy this seafood pot pie while it’s piping hot, and then use any leftover puff pastry to make some Salmon Wellington!