Love seafood and want it delivered to your home? Here are our favorite places to buy seafood online (even if you’re landlocked)!
This year, more and more of us are ordering our food online.
And (interestingly), grocery stores are selling more fish than ever before.
It makes sense.
If you typically order seafood at restaurants, but suddenly you’re not eating out as often, you may decide to cook the fish yourself!
Recently, I’ve been hearing the same question over and over again.
“Where do you buy your seafood?”
Keep reading for some of my favorite options for ordering seafood online.
Looking for fish recipes? Check out all of my seafood recipes here.
Nervous about cooking fish? Try herb butter salmon, broiled cod with lemon sauce and salmon Caesar salad, three of my favorite easy fish recipes.
What Should I Know About Ordering Seafood Online?
Ordering seafood online is an incredibly convenient way to get your favorite fish and crustaceans!
Since the deliveries are perishable, it’s a good idea to keep an eye on your tracking number and get the fish from the box to your freezer or fridge right away (or as quickly as possible).
Keep in mind that the available seafood selections will vary wildly throughout the year, especially with wild-caught fish. Because seafood is seasonal!
For example, King salmon runs are in the summer, so you’ll see it available primarily in the late summer through early winter.
Finally, remember that not all seafood companies are equal.
Some seafood retailers pack the fish in chemicals, or sell fish that wasn’t quickly frozen after catching. In my experience, both the chemicals and slow processing will change the flavor of the fish (for the worse).
Keep reading to see which retailers I recommend!
The Grocery Store
The cheapest option, by far, is going to be your local grocery store.
If you’re looking for seafood but are on a tight budget, check into grocery delivery or curbside pickup.
That said, if you’re looking for seafood to replace the higher-end fish you’d typically get at a nice restaurant, you might not find that at the grocery store.
Can’t find what you’re looking for at your regular grocery store?
Try an online grocery store like Thrive Market!
Thrive Market is a membership-style grocery store that’s stocked with discounted, primarily organic, pantry items. Think of it like an online Costco, but focused on items you’d find in a health store.
But guys, Thrive Market has more than pantry items. It has an absolutely fantastic seafood section.
My readers rave about Thrive Market’s seafood!
You’ll have to order in bulk, so it can be a little pricy up-front, but the options are high-quality and delicious. Right now the seafood boxes are priced from $139 to $169.
Sitka Salmon Shares
Another one of my top recommendations for ordering seafood online is Sitka Salmon Shares.
Sitka Salmon Shares is a Community Supported Fishery (CSF), so your money buys you delicious fish and also helps support Alaska fisherman.
A CSF works differently than a grocery store. If you’re familiar with farmer’s market CSA (Community Supported Agriculture) boxes, it’s a similar concept.
Instead of ordering specific fish, you sign up for a monthly delivery of whatever type of seafood is scheduled for the month.
The type of seafood varies depending on which share option you select, and could change slightly depending on what the fisherman actually catch.
Sitka Salmon Shares is a perfect option for anyone who wants consistent seafood deliveries and loves trying different types of fish!
I’ve been a Sitka Salmon Shares member since early in 2020, and am absolutely thrilled with every order we’ve received.
Want to try out monthly seafood deliveries from Sitka Salmon Shares? Enter the promo code Champ25 during checkout for $25 off your order.
Finally, check into online seafood-specific grocery stores like Vital Choice Wild Seafood & Organics.
With Vital Choice, you can customize a seafood box (like a regular grocery store order) or get monthly recurring deliveries.
Vital Choice has a nice selection of wild-caught, high-end seafood.
Special Mention: Live Shellfish Delivery
Looking for live shellfish delivery?
We’ve ordered from Rappahannock Oysters and I’d highly recommend them!
Friends of ours love Maine Lobster Now for live lobster delivery.
Is there another seafood delivery option that you love? Let me know in the comments!